CLOSED: 5975 N Nagel Street, La Mesa, CA 91942. 3-bedroom 3.5-bath, 2189 sf, 1953 La Mesa $1,270,000 begin new search
Click a button below to contact Buyers' Agent from Compass. Listing Office: CA-RES.
This home is not currently available for sale. Contact us to discuss your options.
Ask A Question Save To Favorites Follow 5975 N Nagel Street

Overview

"WOWCOME" Behind a quiet street and mature trees, this La Mesa home feels tucked away yet close to everything that makes the area special. Set on nearly 10,000 square feet of land, the property comes to you with a newly finished pool, a home that’s been completely remodeled from the inside out with each room feeling like luxury, all coming with their very own full bathrooms. Inside, roughly 1,650 square feet of space have been completely re-imagined. Every surface and system is new — plumbing, electrical, roof, and luxury finishes throughout. No corners were cut in this house. It truly is like nothing that is offered in the area. The open layout connects a warm living space with a brand-new kitchen featuring quartz counters, custom cabinetry, stainless appliances, and an island designed for both cooking and conversation. Each of the three bedrooms includes its own full bathroom, creating flexibility for guests or multi-generational living. The primary suite adds comfort with a double vanity, walk-in shower, and calm, modern design. A half-bath near the main living area keeps things convenient without interrupting the home’s flow. Step out back, surrounded by a top-of-the-line stainless steel fence for privacy and security, it’s easy to picture weekend gatherings or quiet mornings by the fully heated pool and spa. There’s still plenty of room left to garden, expand, or build an with a detached 2-car garage on one side and an expanded shed on the other. This home offers a great opportunity for ADU, home gym, even a man cave — a smart option in this part of La Mesa where space and privacy are hard to find. The result is a home that feels brand new but fits naturally into its surroundings: peaceful, functional, and ready to live in today. With quick access to the Village, Lake Murray, and nearby trails, this property brings together modern living and the charm that keeps people in La Mesa for decades. Rate buy downs and differnt types of financing options could be considerd

Address 5975 N Nagel Street

La Mesa, CA 91942
Listing Status Closed
Sold Price $1,270,000
Asking Price $1,270,000
Original Listing $1,200,000 @ 2025-09-15
Escrow Date 2025-11-20
Closing Date 2025-12-17
Off-Market Date 2025-09-17T19:44:46Z
Days on MLS
Rooms
Attic, Laundry, All Bedrooms Down, Main Floor Primary Bedroom, Kitchen, Living Room, Main Floor Bedroom, Family Room, Primary Bathroom
Square Footage 2189 sf
Bedrooms 3
Full Bathrooms 3
Half Baths 1
Location
Directions Corner house on Nagel St
Market Area 91942 - La Mesa
School District Not Listed
Ownership
Age Restriction 0
Property Type
Mello-Roos Fee $0
HOA Fee $0
HOA Features Street Lights, Sidewalks
Public Records
County San Diego
Assessor Parcel# 4853210900
Zoning Residential
Geographic Areas

Airport Compatibility Zone: Montgomery Field

Community College District: Grossmont-cuyamaca CC

Zip Code: 91942

Highway Locator

East of I-15

East of I-5

North of I-8

East of I-805

East of SR-163

South of SR-52

Ocean Distance 14.0 miles
Exterior
Style Single Family Residence
Material Not Listed
Lot Size ~ 9,600 sf
Fencing Not Listed
Topography Not Listed
Entry Steps 1
Swimming Pool In Ground, Heated
Exclusive Yard 0
Parking
Total Spaces: 2
Garage Spaces: 2
Non-Garage Spaces: 0 -
View None
Features
Year Built 1953
Laundry Location Individual Room
Elevator Not Listed
Cooling Central Air
Heating
Sewer/Septic Public Sewer
Fireplaces Living Room (1)
Additional Parcels No
Appliances No
Assessments No
Association No
Association Fee 2 0
Attached Garage No
Below Grade Finished Area 0
Carport Spaces 0
Common Walls No Common Walls
Cooling Yes
Entry Location Ground floor
Heating No
High School District Grossmont Union
Land Lease No
Laundry Yes
Levels One
Living Area Source Public Records
Lot Features Sprinklers In Front, Corner Lot, 0-1 Unit/Acre, Near Public Transit, Garden, Front Yard, Gentle Sloping, Lawn
Lot Size Source Public Records
Lot Size Units Square Feet
Main Level Bathrooms 0
Main Level Bedrooms 0
New Construction No
Number Of Units Total 0
Number Remotes 0
Parking No
Patio No
Pool Private Yes
Property Attached No
Sprinklers Yes
Tax Model
View No
Well Depth 0
Well Gallons Per Minute 0
Well Pump Horsepower 0
Well Report No
Monthly Payment Calculator
Property Tax estimate of 1% of listing price does not include local voter-approved bonds/assessments, supplemental taxes for new construction or ownership changes, extra local fees, etc.
Listing Source
Platform CRMLS
AOR Pacific Southwest
MLS Number PTP2506881
Courtesy of CA-RES, ShoppingSDHouses
Listing Agent Luis Vega & Dominic Jabro
858-829-5692